Thursday, May 19

American Idol vs. The Voice

The Voice is another one of those talent-seeking shows. The Voice is pretty much a new show to the NBC network. Are you an American Idol fan? If so, do you think by watching this you will want to watch The Voice? If you’re not an American Idol fan, after seeing this do you plan on watching The Voice? What benefits do you think singers will seek from The Voice versus American Idol? Explain. Which show do you like best The Voice or American Idol?

11 comments:

Valarie said...

I have heard about The Voice before from my best friend. I use to watch American Idol all the time but when I started working it ruined my television watching days. I think The Voice looks like a very fun show. It looks like it will help singers know that it is okay to mess up everyone does. I am unsure of which one I like best because I have not seen The Voice. I hope I can see The Voice soon.

Miss. Frizzle said...

I had never heard about The Voice until last week. That is when I watched it last Tuesday and I really enjoyed it. It is a new show on NBC but a lot of people have not heard about or watched it. I think that if the show was to come on earlier more people would watch it. From the show that I watched I think I like The Voice better than idol.

.--->WiLLiE StacKSz<---. said...

I'm not a fan of any of these shows. I don't even watch any of these shows. I do think these singers will benefit from these shows. I like American Idol best though.

Sarah Spencer said...

I am not an American Idol fan. I have watched The Voice once. I think contestants on The Voice have a more fair chance than participants on American Idol. They hopefully cannot be discriminated against due to their looks. I prefer The Voice over American Idol.

Peyton said...

I am a huge Idol fan. I have watched The Voice a couple of times, and really like it. It's funny and has a lot of talented people. The benefits from The Voice would be that all of these singers get to be coached by experienced singers. I still like American Idol the most.

Caleb said...

I don't like talent-searching shows. I don't like American Idol and I am not really interested in The Voice. I'm not saying it's a bad show, but I don't think it's something I would be interested in. I don't think the chairs being turned around should be necessary at all. If they were truly looking for "the voice" of the people, they would listen to the voice and not rely on rotating chairs to hide their faces. You shouldn't judge someone who is trying out to be a singer based on his appearance to begin with. This show just proves how judgmental America is.

Chelsea said...

I'm not a big American Idol fan. The show has changed a lot since I used to watch it. I watch the voice every time I catch it on. It's a very interesting show. I think the voice is better than American Idol, because the people are judged by their voice. American Idol is different, because the judges can look at the contestants, whereas, on
The Voice, the judges can't see the contestants. I definitely like The Voice better than American Idol.

Sam said...

The Voice looks interesting. I might watch this even though I do not watch American Idol. It looks like on the Voice, the celebrities will help them reach their potential. Where as on American Idol, it seems as though all they do is tell the person whether or not they suck. I would probably like the Voice over Idol.

Roielle said...

I’m not really that much of an American Idol fan, but I’ll watch it if I’m bored. I think The Voice is a lot better then The Voice. I think this show will give the contestants publicity. I like the show The Voice better. This is a really good show.

Anonymous said...

I use to watch American Idol all the time, but I do not anymore. I liked it better when Simon and Paula were the judges. I think I will want to watch The Voice. I think the singers will benefit from this by actually interacting more with the judge versus the way American Idol does things. I have never watched The Voice but from the video, I think I would like it better than American Idol.
-Shaquii

Mr. "B" Fr3sh said...

I am not a fan of American Idol. By watching this clip I do would not want to see this. Well I still do not want to see this show. Well I do not know what type of benefits they receive because I am not that informed on these shows. Well I do not watch neither one of the shows, so i can not say that I do not like it.